The Stranger in Chock-Full-o’Nuts

The Stranger in the Chock-Full-o'Nuts by Antoinette Carone

When I first lived in the city, I got a job at Chock-Full-o’Nuts on 57th Street and Eighth Avenue.  One evening a very interesting man came in.  He had piercing eyes.  He sat at my station, ordered black coffee, then asked if I were a student.


“An artist, then?”

“No, I’m an actress.”

“That is being an artist.”

He smiled.  I replaced the coffee pot on the hot plate and when I turned back toward him, he had disappeared.

The man appeared at my workstation each evening for a while.  He always ordered black coffee and a plain doughnut which he nibbled but never seemed to eat.  He would look me over.  He was sly about it, but I was in the habit of observing.  I would smile and offer more coffee.  He would always accept.  Then he would disappear, leaving the extra coffee untouched.  I never heard the opening or closing of the door.

Then, one night he didn’t come.  Nor did he come on subsequent nights.  I missed him for a while, but then forgot about him.

I had been cast as Mrs. Popov in The Boor for a production of three Chekov one-act plays.  On the evening of dress rehearsal, a rainstorm suddenly arose as I was leaving work.  It had been sunny when I left, so I hadn’t thought to bring an umbrella.

All I could do was duck into doorways.  It was raining even harder and I still had a couple of blocks to go when I ducked into the doorway of an apartment building.  I heard a rustling and looked down.  On the side of the entryway was a rat, wet and shivering.  He looked up at me and I backed up against the wall hoping to give him some space to go away.

“Madam, can I help you?”

I blinked and found myself facing the man who had been coming to my workstation.

“Yes, we have met – after a fashion.  You gave me extra coffee at Chock-Full-o’Nuts.  I am Sebastian.”

I looked at the doorway toward the street but was afraid to move.  I didn’t want the rat to come out from wherever it was and scamper across my feet.

“Would you walk out with me? There was a rat here.

He smiled, seemingly with satisfaction.  “A rat will only bite if it feels trapped or if it is hungry.  I will accompany you.  I have an umbrella.”

“Oh, thank you.”

When we reached the rehearsal hall, he asked if I would allow him to offer me dinner some night, although very late.

“Why not?”  I thought to myself

“Why not, indeed,” he responded aloud.

On the night we were to have dinner I finished wiping down my counter area, removed my apron and took my hairnet off.  I closed my eyes and tossed my head to let my hair flow down my back again.  When I opened my eyes, I saw Sebastian standing at my station.

“How did you get in?  I thought the door was locked.”

“Don’t forget – tonight.”  He smiled.

I turned to hang up my apron.  When I spun around again, he was gone.  This doesn’t seem normal, I thought.  I was beginning to wonder.

It was the night of the autumnal equinox; starting tomorrow, night would outlast the day.  Even though it was already dark I decided I would walk home.  I felt safe walking in the dark, even though everyone warned me about how dangerous New York was.  Deep down, I believed I led a charmed life and no harm would befall me.

I was ready when the doorbell rang.  I opened it and there stood Sebastian.  He smiled, and we looked each other up and down for a few seconds.

“Are you going to ask me in?” he said.  “I cannot enter unless you invite me.””

He was carrying an interesting walking stick.  It was walnut, with a carved handle.  It seemed to be the face of a dog.  No, it was a wolf, its forelegs wrapped around the shaft of the walking stick, while its long tail cascaded downward.

“The wolf face looks almost human.”

A slight smile was all he responded.

“Did you inherit the cane from a relative?”

“No.  It was a gift for my twenty-first birthday.  It was new.”

He offered no more information.  New?  Sebastian appeared to be about twenty-eight, but the cane looked antique.  And so began the process of luring me deeper and deeper.


Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating / 5. Vote count:

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this story.

Because you rated this story...

Why not follow us on social media?

About the Author

  1. Avatar Antoinette Carone (1 story )

    My life as a writer began when my husband and I decided to spend a year in Italy. I kept a journal which was later published as Ciao, Napoli. A Scrapbook of Wandering in Naples. I have compiled a book of short stories, titled Siren Shore inspired by our experiences in Italy. My work has appeared on Ovunque Siamo and Foxglove Journal. I am an active member of the New York Writers’ Coalition and of the Italian American Writers’ Association. I hold a bachelor’s degree in Romance Languages and have also been involved in community theater.

4 thoughts on
The Stranger in Chock-Full-o’Nuts

  1. FABULOUS! I sat on the edge of my seat in front of my computer from (almost) the very beginning. I say “almost”, because the first sentence sounded like the usual “how I met my boyfriend or husband”. However, by the time the writer got to “when I turned my back, he had disappeared”, I knew this was no usual story!

    I enjoyed this story enormously! Way to go Antoinette!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By checking the box below, you agree to the website privacy policy and terms of use.